Personal Injury

Can I Still Get a Personal Injury Settlement If…? 9 Situations Explained

Insurance adjusters often suggest that something about your situation – you weren’t wearing a seatbelt, you were uninsured, you had a drink – means you can’t recover anything. Sometimes that is true, but usually it isn’t. In most cases these facts reduce a claim rather than eliminate it, and the answer depends heavily on your state. Here are the most common situations.

1. If I was a passenger in the accident

Passengers are usually in the strongest position of anyone in a crash, because they are rarely at fault. A passenger can claim against the driver who caused the accident – including the driver of the car they were riding in – and sometimes against both drivers. Coverage may come from the at-fault driver’s liability policy, the policy on the car you were in, your own policy (MedPay, PIP or uninsured motorist), or, in no-fault states, PIP first. Claiming against a friend’s or relative’s insurance is not suing them personally in practice; their insurer defends and pays. A handful of situations, such as knowingly riding with a drunk driver, can reduce a passenger’s recovery under comparative fault.

2. If I was not wearing a seatbelt

Not wearing a seatbelt does not cause a crash, so it does not make you at fault for the accident itself. The question is whether the defense can use it to reduce damages for injuries the belt would have prevented. States are split: many states bar or sharply limit “seatbelt defense” evidence, while others allow it to reduce damages, sometimes only by a capped percentage. Expect the insurer to raise it either way.

3. If I was uninsured at the time of the accident

Driving without insurance is illegal, but in most states it does not stop you from claiming against the driver who caused the crash. However, several states have “no pay, no play” laws that restrict uninsured drivers’ recovery. California (Civil Code § 3333.4) bars uninsured drivers from recovering non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, and Louisiana bars uninsured drivers from recovering the first $15,000 of bodily injury and $25,000 of property damage. Michigan and other no-fault states limit uninsured owners’ access to PIP and to some tort claims. You may still face penalties for driving uninsured.

4. If I was hit by a driver who fled (hit and run)

If the other driver cannot be identified, your own uninsured motorist (UM) coverage generally treats them as uninsured and pays your injury claim. Some states and policies also cover property damage under uninsured motorist property damage coverage. Policies usually require that you report the hit-and-run to police promptly (often within 24 hours to a few days) and notify your insurer quickly. Many states require evidence of physical contact or an independent witness for “phantom vehicle” claims where the other car never touched you. MedPay and PIP also apply. If police later identify the driver, you can claim against their insurance.

5. If I was on the job at the time of the accident

Injuries at work are covered by workers’ compensation, which pays medical bills and part of lost wages without proving fault. In exchange, you generally cannot sue your employer. But if a third party caused the injury – another driver while you were driving for work, a negligent contractor, a defective machine – you can bring a personal injury claim against them as well. That claim can include pain and suffering, which workers’ comp does not pay. The workers’ comp insurer will usually have a lien on the third-party recovery for what it paid.

6. If I was under the influence of drugs or alcohol

Intoxication is evidence of fault but not an automatic bar. Under comparative negligence, a jury may assign you a share of the blame – potentially a large one – and reduce your recovery or, in modified comparative states, bar it if your share exceeds the threshold. Some states go further: California bars a driver convicted of DUI for the incident from recovering non-economic damages. If you were injured by someone else who was drunk, many states’ dram shop laws allow claims against a bar or restaurant that served a visibly intoxicated person.

7. If I was breaking the law at the time of the accident

A traffic violation – speeding, an illegal turn – is treated as evidence of your own negligence (sometimes negligence per se), which reduces your recovery under your state’s fault rule. It does not usually eliminate your claim if the other driver was also at fault. What matters is whether your violation contributed to the crash: driving with an expired registration, for example, did not cause anything.

8. If I was injured while committing a crime

This is where recovery is most limited. Many states bar or restrict claims by people injured while committing a felony, either by statute (California Civil Code § 3333.3 bars recovery for injuries suffered during the commission of a felony, or flight from one, for which the person was convicted) or under the “wrongful conduct” rule. Even so, property owners and police can be liable for using excessive force, and a burglar’s claim against a homeowner is very different from a claim by someone with a minor offense unrelated to the injury.

9. If I was not physically injured

You can claim for property damage without any injury. Recovering for emotional distress without physical injury is harder. Most states allow negligent infliction of emotional distress claims only in limited circumstances – for example, if you were in the “zone of danger” and feared for your safety, or witnessed a close family member being seriously injured. Psychological injuries diagnosed by a professional, such as PTSD after a crash, are more likely to be compensable. Remember that damages for purely emotional harm are generally taxable.

The common thread: your state’s rules

In nearly every scenario above, the outcome depends on your state’s fault rule, insurance laws and statute of limitations. Check the comparative negligence rule and filing deadline for your state, and consider a free consultation with a personal injury lawyer before accepting an adjuster’s statement that you have no claim.