- The privilege can be lost by waiver (the client’s conduct) or may never apply because of an exception (the type of communication).
- The most common waivers are sharing privileged material with outsiders and relying on legal advice as part of your own claim or defense.
- Federal Rule of Evidence 502 limits the damage of accidental disclosures and of “subject-matter” waiver in federal proceedings.
- The crime-fraud exception removes protection from communications made to further a crime or fraud.
Attorney-client privilege is powerful, but it is fragile. Courts protect it because it encourages honest communication with lawyers; they construe it narrowly because it keeps relevant evidence out of court. The result is a body of rules about when the privilege is waived and when it does not apply at all. This guide covers the situations courts see most often. For the basics of what the privilege covers, start with our attorney-client privilege guide.
Who can waive the privilege?
Only the holder – the client – can waive. For an individual that is the client personally (or, after death, usually the personal representative). For a company it is management. A lawyer can waive on the client’s behalf when acting within their authority, for example by producing documents in discovery, but an employee who leaks company emails without authority generally does not waive the company’s privilege.
Express and voluntary disclosure
The clearest waiver is deliberately revealing a privileged communication to someone outside the privilege: forwarding your lawyer’s email to a friend, quoting legal advice in a press release, or testifying about what your lawyer told you. Once confidentiality is voluntarily broken, the protection is gone for that communication.
Disclosure to third parties works the same way. Bringing a relative into a meeting, discussing advice on a crowded train, or copying a business partner on an email can all destroy confidentiality. The exception is a third party who is necessary to the legal advice – an interpreter, a paralegal, or an expert retained by the lawyer.
Inadvertent disclosure
In large document productions, privileged documents slip through. In federal proceedings, Rule 502(b) provides that an inadvertent disclosure is not a waiver if the holder took reasonable steps to prevent it and promptly took reasonable steps to fix it, such as following the “clawback” procedure in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(5)(B). Parties often go further and ask the court for a Rule 502(d) order, which can provide that production in the case is not a waiver at all.
State courts have their own approaches, ranging from strict (any disclosure waives) to lenient (only intentional disclosure waives); most use a multi-factor reasonableness test.
Subject-matter waiver
A party cannot disclose the helpful parts of its legal advice and hide the rest. If you intentionally disclose a privileged communication, a court may find that the waiver extends to other undisclosed communications on the same subject. Under Rule 502(a), in federal proceedings this happens only when the waiver was intentional, the disclosed and undisclosed communications concern the same subject matter, and they “ought in fairness” be considered together.
Implied waiver and putting advice “at issue”
Privilege can also be waived by conduct, without any disclosure. The classic example is the advice-of-counsel defense: if a defendant argues “I acted in good faith because my lawyer told me it was legal,” the defendant has put the lawyer’s advice at issue and must disclose it. Other examples:
- Suing your former lawyer for malpractice waives the privilege as to communications relevant to the claim, so the lawyer can defend themselves.
- Claiming you did not understand a settlement or contract may open up what your lawyer told you about it.
- Claiming that a statute of limitations should be tolled because you did not know about a claim may expose when your lawyer told you.
Courts use different tests for “at issue” waiver – some require that the party affirmatively rely on the advice, others apply it more broadly – so this is a frequent battleground. Courts also sometimes describe a party as estopped from asserting privilege after taking inconsistent positions, which works the same way in practice.
Joint clients and joint representation
When two or more clients hire the same lawyer on a matter of common interest – business partners, spouses doing estate planning, co-defendants – their communications with that lawyer are privileged against the outside world. But between the joint clients themselves, there is generally no privilege. If the partners later sue each other over the same matter, either can use the communications from the joint representation. Lawyers usually explain this in the engagement letter before agreeing to a joint representation.
The common interest doctrine
Separately represented parties who share a common legal interest – for example, co-defendants in the same lawsuit – can share privileged information through their lawyers without waiving the privilege. Most courts require that the interest be legal rather than purely commercial, and many require that litigation be pending or anticipated. The arrangement should be documented in a written common-interest or joint-defense agreement, and the information should be shared lawyer-to-lawyer.
Former clients and successors in interest
- Former clients keep their privilege after the representation ends; a lawyer cannot later reveal those communications, and conflict rules prevent the lawyer from using them against the former client.
- Corporate successors. When a company is acquired or merges, control of its privilege generally passes to the successor that takes over the business. In bankruptcy, the trustee controls the corporate debtor’s privilege (CFTC v. Weintraub, 1985) and may waive it, for example to pursue claims against former managers.
- Estates. The privilege survives death. A recognized exception allows disclosure in disputes between people claiming through the deceased client – such as a will contest – because revealing what the client wanted serves the client’s own intent.
Government clients
Government agencies and officials can hold attorney-client privilege for communications with government lawyers. Federal courts have, however, refused to let government lawyers withhold evidence of crimes from a federal grand jury in some circumstances, and public-records laws can override confidentiality where the statute says so. Government privileges such as the deliberative process privilege are separate doctrines.
The crime-fraud exception
Communications made to further a future or ongoing crime or fraud are not privileged. It does not matter whether the lawyer knew. The exception does not apply to a client seeking advice about a past crime – that is precisely what the privilege protects. A party trying to invoke the exception must make a threshold showing; under United States v. Zolin (1989), a judge may review the communications privately (in camera) once there is a factual basis for a good-faith belief that the exception applies.
Other exceptions
- Disputes between lawyer and client – fee disputes and malpractice claims – allow disclosure as far as necessary.
- Attested documents – a lawyer who witnessed a will can testify about its execution.
- Operation of law – some statutes require disclosures that override confidentiality, and courts may order disclosure of non-privileged parts of documents.
- Testimony in judicial proceedings – if you testify about privileged communications in one proceeding, you will usually be unable to claim privilege over them in a later one.
Does a disclaimer protect me?
No. Email disclaimers and “privileged” stamps do not prevent waiver if the communication is shared outside the privilege, and they cannot create privilege for business communications. Conversely, a lawyer’s disclaimer that “no attorney-client relationship is formed” (common on websites and in free consultations) may mean that what you share is not treated as a privileged consultation. Read such disclaimers before sending sensitive information.
Quick reference
| Situation | Privilege usually… |
|---|---|
| Forwarding lawyer’s email to a friend | Waived for that communication |
| Accidentally producing a privileged document, then promptly clawing it back | Preserved (federal Rule 502(b)) |
| Relying on “my lawyer said it was legal” as a defense | Waived as to that advice |
| Joint clients later suing each other | No privilege between them |
| Co-defendants’ lawyers sharing strategy under a joint-defense agreement | Preserved |
| Asking a lawyer how to hide assets from creditors | Not privileged (crime-fraud) |
| Asking a lawyer how to defend a past crime | Privileged |
Work product protection – the separate shield for materials prepared for litigation – has different waiver rules. See attorney work product explained.