- A demand letter is your formal settlement request to the insurer, with the evidence that supports it.
- Send it after you finish treatment or reach maximum medical improvement, and well before the filing deadline.
- Be specific, factual and organized. Attach records; don’t just describe them.
The demand letter is usually the most important document in a personal injury claim that settles without a lawsuit. It tells the adjuster what happened, why their insured is responsible, what your injuries cost you, and what it will take to resolve the claim. A well-documented demand gives the adjuster what they need to justify a higher settlement internally.
When to send it
Send the demand once your medical picture is clear – after treatment ends or your doctor says you have reached maximum medical improvement. If you will need future treatment, get a written opinion on what it will be and what it will cost. Do not wait so long that you are close to the statute of limitations; insurers take months to respond, and a lawsuit has to be filed before the deadline regardless of negotiations.
Outline of a personal injury demand letter
- Header: your name and contact details, the adjuster’s name, the insurer, the claim number, the insured’s name and the date of the incident. Mark it “For settlement purposes only.”
- Facts of the incident: a short, neutral, chronological account. Date, time, location, what happened. Refer to the police report and photos.
- Liability: why the insured is at fault – the traffic law they broke, the hazard they ignored, witness statements, citations.
- Injuries and treatment: each diagnosis and the treatment you received, in order: emergency room, imaging, specialists, therapy, surgery. Quote doctors’ notes where helpful.
- Medical expenses: an itemized table of providers, dates and amounts billed. Attach the bills.
- Lost income: days missed, your rate of pay, and lost benefits, supported by an employer letter or pay records.
- Future damages: future treatment, reduced earning capacity, with supporting medical opinions.
- Pain, suffering and impact on your life: concrete examples – sleep problems, missed events, activities you can no longer do, help you needed at home. Specific details persuade more than adjectives.
- The demand: a specific dollar amount and a reasonable deadline to respond (commonly 30 days).
- Enclosures list of every document attached.
How to choose the number
Add up your economic damages, then add a figure for non-economic damages; insurers and lawyers often use a multiple of medical expenses as a starting point. Try the settlement calculator. Demand more than you expect to accept so you have room to negotiate, but keep it defensible – an absurd figure signals you are not serious. If you know the at-fault party’s policy limits and your damages clearly exceed them, a policy-limits demand may be appropriate.
Time-limited and policy-limits demands
A demand to settle within the policy limits by a specific date can expose an insurer to “bad faith” liability beyond the limits if it unreasonably refuses. Because of this, several states, including Georgia and Florida, have statutes setting out what such time-limited demands must contain and how long the insurer must be given to respond. These rules are technical, and a defective demand can backfire – this is one area where a lawyer is particularly valuable.
Common mistakes
- Sending it too early, before the full extent of injuries is known.
- Admitting partial fault or apologizing for the accident.
- Exaggerating – adjusters will compare your letter with your medical records.
- Leaving out documents or sending them piecemeal.
- Including your entire medical history – send records relevant to the injury, not unrelated conditions.
- Accepting the first offer or responding emotionally to a low one. Reply in writing, explain why the offer is too low, and make a counteroffer.
- Forgetting liens – health insurers and government programs may have to be repaid from the settlement.
What happens next
The adjuster may accept, reject, ask for more information, or (most commonly) make a lower counteroffer. Negotiation can take several rounds. If you reach an agreement, you will sign a release; read it carefully before signing. If you cannot agree, the next step is filing a lawsuit – see the personal injury process.